|
Sign In to gain access to subscriptions and/or personal tools.
|
Scope for bottom-up planning in Kolkata: rhetoric vs reality
Anirban Pal
Environmental Design Building, Campus Box 314, University of Colorado at Boulder, Boulder, CO 80309, USA, pal{at}colorado.edu
This paper describes the process of metropolitan planning and decision making in Kolkata, India. Despite widespread belief that West Bengal has been a pioneer in democratic decentralization in India, this paper argues that the dominance of one political party and its hierarchical structure has thwarted the scope for effective bottom-up metropolitan planning in Kolkata. It questions the unchallenged dominance of partisan political actors in public decision making at the local level, and suggests a greater role for non-partisan and locally based civil society organizations. The case also demonstrates that these processes call for expertise in communicative people-centred practices and for shrewd strategic actors who understand the power dynamics of the wider political context. It highlights the need for policy makers to focus on the design of institutional mechanisms that allow for a more bottom-up approach to metropolitan planning through which to address common problems and define shared objectives.
Key Words: democratic decentralization • Kolkata • partisan politics • urban governance
References
- Appadurai, A (2001), "Deep democracy: urban governmentality and the horizon of politics" , Public Culture Vol 14, pages 22-46 .
- Appadurai, A (2004), "The capacity to aspire: culture and the terms of recognition", in V Rao and M Walton (editors), Culture and Public Action, Stanford University Press, Stanford, California . Asian Coalition for Housing Rights website: (http://www.achr.net/impacts.htm).
- Bandyopadhyay, D (2000), "Planning from below: is planning commission performing its role?" , Economic and Political Weekly Vol 34, 18 March, pages 982-983 .
- Banerjee, T and S Chakravorty (1994), "Transfer of planning technology and local political economy - a retrospective analysis of Calcutta’s planning" , Journal of the American Planning Association Vol 60, No 1, pages 71-82 .[CrossRef][Web of Science]
- Benjamin, S (2000), "Governance, economic settings and poverty in Bangalore" , Environment & Urbanization Vol 12, No 1, April, pages 35-56 .[Medline]
[Order article via Infotrieve]
- Berg, L, H A Klinket al. (1993), Governing Metropolitan Regions, Avebury, Aldershot, UK .
- Bhattacharya, M (1998), "Municipal planning in the perspective of 74th Amendment" , Nagarlok Vol 30, No 4, pages 1-7 .
- Bhaumik, S (2005), "India sex workers demand rights", BBC News Online , website: http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/south_asia/4256412.stm.
- Burra, S (2005), "Towards a pro-poor framework for slum upgrading in Mumbai, India" , Environment & Urbanization Vol 17, No 1, April, pages 67-88 .[CrossRef]
- Cabannes, Y (2004), "Participatory budgeting: a signifi-cant contribution to participatory democracy" , Environment & Urbanization Vol 16, No 1, April, pages 27-46 .
- D’Cruz, C and D Satterthwaite (2005), "Building homes, changing official approaches: the work of urban poor organizations and their federations, and their contributions to meeting the Millennium Development Goals in urban areas", Working Paper No 16 in Poverty Reduction in Urban Areas Series, IIED, London .
- Doig, J W (1995), "Politics and the engineering mind: O H Ammann and the hidden story of the George Washington bridge", in D C Perry (editor), Building the Public City: The Politics, Governance and Finance of Public Infrastructure, Sage Publications, Thousand Oaks, London, New Delhi , pages 21-70.
- Etemadi, F (2004), "The politics of engagement: gains and challenges of the NGO coalition in Cebu City" , Environment & Urbanization Vol 16, No 1, April, pages 79-93 .
- Flyvbjerg, B (1998), Rationality and Power: Democracy in Practice, University of Chicago Press, Chicago, IL .
- Flyvbjerg, B (2004), "Five misunderstandings about case study research", in C Seale, G Gobo, J F Gubrium and D Silverman (editors), Qualitative Research Practice, Sage Publications, London, Thousand Oaks, New Delhi , pages 420-434.
- Forester, J (1989), Planning in the Face of Power, University of California Press, Berkeley; also Innes, J E (1996), "Planning through consensus building - a new view of the comprehensive planning SCOPE FOR BOTTOM-UP PLANNING IN KOLKATA ideal" , Journal of the American Planning Association Vol 62, No 4, pages 460-472 .[CrossRef][Web of Science]
- Friedmann, J (2004), "Globalization and the emerging culture of planning", revised Paper for Chapter 7 of UN-Habitat , State of the World’s Cities - 2004.
- Friend, J K and W N Jessop (1969), Local Government and Strategic Choice: An Operational Research Approach to the Processes of Public Planning, Tavistock Publications, London .
- Ghosh, Arun (1988), "Decentralized planning - West Bengal experience" , Economic and Political Weekly Vol 23, No 13, page 655-655 .
- Ghosh, Arun (1988), "Popular participation and decentralized planning" , Economic and Political Weekly, 16 January, pages 66-68 .
- Gualini, E (2001), Planning and the Intelligence of Institutions: Interactive Approaches to Territorial Policy-making between Institutional Design and Institution-building, Ashgate, Aldershot, UK .
- Huxley, M (2000), "The limits to communicative planning" , Journal of Planning Education and Research Vol 19, No 4, pages 369-377 .[Abstract/Free Full Text]
- Kitchen, T (1997), People, Politics, Policies and Plans: The City Planning Process in Contemporary Britain, Paul Chapman Publishing, London .
- Kolkata Metropolitan Development Authority (2001), Vision 2025: Perspective Plan of CMA (Interim Draft), Kolkata Metropolitan Development Authority .
- Mageli, E (2001), NGO Activism in Calcutta 1973-1997: Exploring Unnayan, Faculty of Arts, University of Oslo .
- Mageli, E (2004), "Housing mobilization in Calcutta - empowerment for the masses or awareness for the few?" , Environment & Urbanization Vol 16, No 1, April, pages 129-137 .
- Mathew, G (2003), "West Bengal - still a role model for panchayat raj" , PUCL Bulletin, July.
- Meyerson, N M and E C Banfield (1955), Politics, Planning and Public Interest: The Case of Public Housing in Chicago, Free Press, New York .
- Mitlin, D (2004), "Reshaping local democracy" , Environment & Urbanization Vol 16, No 1, April, pages 3-8 .
- Mitlin, D (2004), "Civil society organizations: do they make a difference to urban poverty?", in N Devas (editor), Urban Governance, Voice and Poverty in the Developing World, Earthscan, London, Sterling, VA , pages 123-144.
- Namboodiri, U (2005), Bengal’s Night Without End, India First Foundation, New Delhi .
- Pinto, M R (2000), Metropolitan City Governance in India, Sage Publications, New Delhi, Thousand Oaks, London .
- Rao, V and M Walton (2004), "Culture and public action: relationality, equality of agency, and development", in V Rao and M Walton (editors), Culture and Public Action, Stanford University Press, Stanford, California , pages 3-36.
- Rudolph, S H (2000), "Civil society and the realm of freedom" , Economic and Political Weekly Vol 35, No 20, pages 1762-1769 .
- Sanyal, B and M Tewari (1990), Politics and Institutions in Urban Development: The Story of the Calcutta Metropolitan Development Authority, Economic Development Institute of the World Bank, Washington DC .
- Sanyal, S (2004), "Unfair poll: West Bengal bracketed with Bihar" , The Statesman, 6 May, Kolkata .
- Sanyal, S (2005), "Bogus Bengalis: hasn’t Alimuddin Street created some?" , The Statesman, 15 February, Kolkata .
- Sarkar, Abhirup (2006), "Political economy of West Bengal: a puzzle and a hypothesis" , Economic and Political Weekly 28 January, pages 341-348 .
- Savitch, H V and R K Vogel (editors) (1996), Regional Politics: America in a Post-City Age, Sage Publications, Thousand Oaks, London, New Delhi .
- Shaw, A (1999), "Emerging patterns of urban growth in India" , Economic and Political Weekly Vol 34, Nos 16/17, pages 969-978 .
- Shourie, A (2004), Governance and the Sclerosis that has Set In, ASA Rupa & Co, New Delhi .
- State Planning Board (1990), A Perspective Plan for Calcutta: 2011, Development and Planning Department, State Planning Board, Government of West Bengal, Calcutta .
- The Statesman (2002), "Gimmicks galore: fragmented opposition only helps Left Front" , 24 February, Kolkata .
- The Statesman News Service (2005), "Ballot blows land thick & fast" , 19 June, Kolkata .
- The Telegraph (2006), "Card games" , 16 January 2006, Kolkata , page 1-1 .
- Thomas Isaac, T M and R W Franke (2002), Local Democracy and Development: The Kerala People’s Campaign for Decentralized Planning, Rowman & Littlefield, Lanham, MD .
- UN-Habitat (2001), Cities in a Globalizing World: Global Report on Human Settlements 2001, Earthscan, London and Sterling, VA .
- Yiftachel, O (2000), "Social control, urban planning and ethno-class relations: Mizrahi Jews in Israel’s ‘development towns’" , International Journal of Urban and Regional Research Vol 24, No 2, pages 418-438 .[CrossRef][Web of Science]
Environment and Urbanization, Vol. 18, No. 2,
501-521 (2006)
DOI: 10.1177/0956247806069628
 CiteULike  Complore  Connotea  Del.icio.us  Digg  Reddit  Technorati  Twitter What's this?
|
|
